Best motion picture of the year8. Brooklyn
For It: Everyone seems to love Brooklyn, which was popular with critics, and audiences (for a indie), and is a film that you never really hear a bad word about. It’s a beautiful, old fashioned film – the kind the Academy likes quite a bit.
Against It: No director nominated, and despite period work, not “below the the line nominations” either. You need to be able to win a few awards as support for a Best Picture win – and with three total nominations, Brooklyn doesn’t much have a chance to do that.
7. Bridge of SpiesFor It: It’s Spielberg – who they always like. It’s a Cold War Spy Thriller, but a classy one, with contemporary resonance as well. It’s got one of the most beloved stars in the world as well, and just screams Oscar in many ways.
Against It: The enthusiasm for the movie is certainly been muted. They love Spielberg, but didn’t nominate him this year – they love Hanks as well, and didn’t nominate him either. That pretty much spells doom for the chances for this film actually winning.
6. The MartianFor It: The highest grossing film nominated – a much loved audience, friendly hit, with a respected director, one of the biggest stars in the world, and a film that even its detractors seem to at the very least enjoy. Who really hates The Martian?
Against It: But who really loves it either? Sometimes being really well liked by everyone is enough – but with no Ridley Scott nominated for director, that probably means this isn’t winning this year. Argo did it, but the outpouring of support for Scott being “snubbed” as it was for Affleck.
5. RoomFor It: The film got off to a hot start – great reviews in Telluride, audience award in TIFF – and then seemingly kind of fizzled for a while. But those reports were wrong, as Room not only got in for Picture, it also got a director nomination. They clearly liked it.
Against It: But with only four nominations, it’s going to be tough to actually get the kind of supporting wins to take the Best Picture prize. It will likely to have to settle for Best Actress.
4. Mad Max: Fury RoadFor It: With 10 nominations, the film is quite clearly loved by the Academy, as the went in whole hog for the type of film they usually ignore. George Miller is very well respected, and the film is probably the critics favorite of the year – it won pretty much every (American) film critics survey it could.
Against It: Still, action movies don’t win the Best Picture Oscar. No film since 1932’s Grand Hotel has won the Best Picture Oscar with no actors and no screenplay nominated – which Mad Max: Fury Road has to face. It doesn’t really have the Oscar feel to it, does it?
3. SpotlightFor It: It has been the de facto frontrunner since it debuted at Telluride, and has quietly chugged along all season. Everyone likes the film, it hasn’t faced too much of a backlash, and it seems like an important film, with a great ensemble. Have you heard anything really negative about this film all season?
Against It: Is it enough? From the beginning, people questioned if the film was perhaps too quiet, too reserved to actually win the Best Picture Oscar – and others compare it to TV (unfair, but a reality). All season people waited for something to take it over – and perhaps The Big Short has finally done that.
2. The Big ShortFor It: The film broke late in the season, after seemingly being an afterthought for most of it. But once it came out, it came out strong, and has buzzed along all season, with little backlash. It continues to show up everywhere it needs to – and winning the PGA, which is the only other Industry award with a preferential ballot (and since both it and the Academy moved to that, they have always matched – small sample size, but still). While the film is extremely entertaining, it is also very timely.
Against It: Is it a little too entertaining? A little too bro-y? A little too comic? Are they really giving the Best Picture Oscar to the director of Anchorman?
1. The RevenantFor It: With 12 it is the nominations leader, which often shows the kind of broad support that can propel it to victory. It’s also got one of the biggest stars in the world – on the way to winning the Best Actor Oscar – and they clearly loved Alejandro G. Innaritu – after all, he won Picture/Director/Screenplay last year for Birdman.
Against It: Do they love him enough to give him back-to-back Best Picture Oscars (something no director has ever done before). Does the lack of a screenplay nomination mean something? Do they admire the craft of the film more than the film itself. Out of all of the films nominated, it probably has the most vocal detractors (that didn’t hurt Birdman, but still).
Who Will Win: The Revemamt. A legitimate three way race – The Big Short won the Producer’s Guild, which is the only other award to use the weight ballot the Academy does for Best Picture, so it’s a good bet. SAG went with Spotlight – and since actors make up the largest branch, it’s not out of it either. Mind you, the Director’s Guild has a long history of predicting this, and they went with The Revenant – as did BAFTA and the Golden Globes, meaning that the wins keep piling up for The Revenant, and so it’s probably the safest bet. Still, no one really knows, and it could go any number of ways.Who Should Win: Mad Max: Fury Road. Out of the nominees, there really was no better film, no greater technical achievement, and no more entertaining film. Out of the nominees, I think there’s little question, that Mad Max: Fury Road will last the longest.
Least of the Nominees: The Reverant. A long, slow slog to nowhere. Yes, it is brilliantly made, but it’s service of a whole lot of nothing.
Best Director5. Lenny Abrahamson, Room
For Him: An up and coming director, who they clearly quite liked, since he wasn’t on many people’s predictions heading into nomination day – and he got in, over bigger names like Ridley Scott.
Against Him: The nomination for him is a huge award in itself – and will help his career. That will have to be enough for him.
4. Adam McKay, The Big Short
For Him: The Big Short has been gathering momentum all season long, and if it really is going to be the best picture winner, he has a legitimate shot at winning. There’s more flash here than say in Spotlight.
Against Him: Again, this is Adam McKay, who has always been a fine filmmaker, but I cannot help but think the Academy may require him to make another film or two like this, and not Anchorman, before giving him a Best Director Oscar. Screenplay? Sure, but not director.
3. Tom McCarthy, SpotlightFor Him: Despite what they said about Affleck in the Argo year, actors turned directors actually do have a good track record here – even if McCarthy was never really a movie star. He is well respected, quietly building a solid resume as a filmmaker (forget The Cobbler), and has crafted a classically structured film everyone loves. If this wins Best Picture, he could easily win director.
Against Him: There are bigger, flashier films this year – and since expanding the Best Picture nominee pool, they’ve split Picture and Director often – quite often going with a bigger film for Director, and quieter one for Picture. His is the quieter one.
2. George Miller, Mad Max: Fury RoadFor Him: He is a veteran (far more than any of the other nominees), and well respected. He also pushed himself further than ever before, and crafted one hell of an action movie. He is the critics choice, winning more than anyone else. It also more show-offy than any of the films, and in a year that looks like it could be a split, he’s in a good position.
Against Him: Action movies, no matter how great, never really win this prize. The debate all year wasn’t whether Miller would win, it was whether he could be nominated. Will the Academy go with Miller, and this type of film here, when they’ve never really done before?
1. Alejandro G. Iñárritu , The RevenantFor Him: They clearly love him, as he won last year, and while no one has directed two Best Picture winners back-to-back – a few have won back-to-back directing Oscars. They clearly admire the film a great deal, so it’s not out of the realm of possibilities.
Against Him: This is a more divisive film than even Birdman was – and there’s lot of options this year. He won three last year, does he need another so soon?
Who Will Win: Alejandro G. Innaritu, The Revenant. When the nominations came out, I didn’t think it was possible for him to win – but he keeps piling on the wins, and its hard to make a case for someone else winning. Still not convinced Miller cannot pull off an upset – but it would clearly be an upset at this point.Who Should Win: George Miller, Mad Max: Fury Road. It really isn’t close out of these nominees – one crafted a film for the ages, and the rest didn’t. Miller gets my vote easily.
Least of the Nominees: Alejandro G. Innaritu, The Reverant. Innaritu is constantly calling attention himself and his artistry instead of the movie itself, and frankly, his film is the worst of the nominees.
Best Actor5. Eddie Redmayne, The Danish Girl
For Him: People still think it’s “brave” for straight actors to play gay or transgender characters – and that is often enough to get him some votes.
Against Him: He won last year, and in order to win back to back, you need to be either a beloved actor, or have an undeniable performance – he has neither. This was supposed to be one of the big Oscar films of the year – and it wasn’t.
4. Michael Fassbender, Steve JobsFor Him: He is building a solid resume, and this is his second nomination. There will be those who are ready to give him the prize already because he’s due – and also because it’s a show-offy performance, central to every scene, with a ton of dialogue, that he handles with ease.
Against Him: Like The Danish Girl, Steve Jobs was supposed to be one of the big Oscar films of the year, and it didn’t turn out that way. Audiences rejected the film. I think they want to give Fassbender an Oscar – they’ll just have to wait for another year to do so.
3. Matt Damon, The MartianFor Him: They didn’t nominate a more entertaining performance than Damon’s here. It’s a big, movie star performance, where he basically had to act with himself for most of the running time. The really like the film, that isn’t likely to win anything else major, so they may go here.
Against Him: They like movie stars to “disappear” into roles – and Damon doesn’t. Movie stars win Oscars all the time, but not for their big, movie star performances. It just isn’t his year.
2. Bryan Cranston, TrumboFor Him: A well respected actor, in a performance they obviously quite liked, since despite the fact that the movie fizzled, they still found a spot for him in the final five. They love old school Hollywood films – and this is it. If there is an upset coming here, it will be Cranston.
Against Him: There isn’t an upset coming. He is well-respected, but for TV work – the nomination is his initiation into the movie actors club – and he’ll have to wait until at least his next nomination until he wins.
1.Leonardo DiCaprio, The RevenantFor Him: He is overdue for a win, and has been the frontrunner all year – well before anyone even saw the film. This is a very weak category, and no one really ever challenged DiCaprio’s supposed overdue victory. They like the film quite a bit, and it’s likely not to win another major award, so it’s his.
Against Him: Name a another performance that is this quiet that has won a Lead Actor Oscar? I cannot. He doesn’t actually do all that much. DiCaprio is long overdue for a win, but for this?
Who Will Win: Leonardo DiCaprio, The Revenant. It’s not really close this year. This is a lock.Who Should Win: Michael Fassbender, Steve Jobs. I really want to abstain here – not only was this a weak year in general for this category, they nominated poorly as well. Fassbender is the best of the lot, but there should be better choices available.
Least of the Nominees: Eddie Redmayne, The Danish Girl. Redmayne does try hard here to be sure – but the film doesn’t understand this character, and does nothing with her. Redmayne is a talented actor, but to me, I’m still really waiting for a movie to use him better.
Best Actress5. Jennifer Lawrence, Joy
For Her: She’s Jennifer Lawrence, and who doesn’t love Jennifer Lawrence? This is her fourth nomination – and at the age of 25, she is the youngest ever to get that many. The way her career is going, she’ll win a second Oscar sooner or later.
Against Her: But it will be later than this year. Joy was supposed to be a major Oscar player – and this ended up as its only nomination. No one much likes the film, and although many admire Lawrence for making the film work as much as it does, that’s not the same thing as it being a great performance.
4. Cate Blanchett, CarolFor Her: She is one of the Academy’s favorite actresses right now – picking up her 7th nomination for Carol. Those are numbers where a third Oscar doesn’t seem so bad. Add in the fact that Carol is a critics favorite, and she’ll draw some vote.
Against Her: Not many though. Her second win was only a couple of years ago, so there’s no need to rush to give her a third Oscar. Remember, it took Meryl nearly 30 years between Oscars 2 and 3. There are other performances they simply like more.
3. Charlotte Rampling, 45 Years
For Her: A well regarded veteran actress, who has been acting since the 1960s – in acclaimed films no less – and yet has never been nominated for an Oscar until now – there will be some who see a vote for her as a deserved, de facto lifetime achievement award. This is arguably the critics favorite of the year
Against Her: It is the film’s only nomination – and she’s going up against two more highly visable and talked about performances. Her comments against diversity – even after she clarified – won’t win her many votes.
2. Saoirse Ronan, BrooklynFor Her: A brilliant young actress, already on nomination #2 and only in her early 20s. Her work in Brooklyn is subtle, heartbreaking and warmly human – and it’s a film they clearly like, as it snuck into the Best Picture Race. If there is an upset coming, I think it’s coming from her, and not Rampling.
Against Her: She really needed that one win to put her more in play against the actress who has been the frontrunner since September – and she never got it. She’s so young, it’s hard not to argue that she’ll have another chance.
1. Brie Larson, RoomFor Her: She has been the frontrunner since the film did the Telluride-Toronto two step in September, and despite the fact that the film didn’t do well at the box office, it held steady all awards season – even getting into the Best Picture lineup as a surprise. Larson has been around for a while, doing great work, and she outdoes herself here. Yes, she’s a newcomer – but that doesn’t hurt that much here.
Against Her: Not a lot really. She’s as big a lock as Leo.
Who Will Win: Brie Larson, Room. I sort of expected that Ronan or Rampling was going to make a race out of this, but that never really happened. Larson wins easily.Who Should Win: Saorise Ronan, Brooklyn. Really, anyone except Lawrence would be a worthy winner. If we’re strictly on merit, than it’s a tossup between Ronan and Rampling, and since Ronan didn’t utter something as silly as “racist to whites”, she’ll get by vote.
Least of the Nominees: Jennifer Lawrence, Joy. This was such as amazing year in this category, they could have found easily a dozen worthier nominees than Lawrence. I really do like Lawrence – but she cannot save Joy from itself.
Best Supporting Actor5. Christian Bale, The Big Short
For Him: The Big Short has become one of the surprise frontrunners in the Oscar race – and Best Picture winners (which it may be) often win an acting award – and he’s the film’s lone shot.
Against Him: I’m still kind of mystified as how Bale ended up being considered Best in Show in a film full of great performances – it’s fine work, but deliberately one note. Plus, unlike everyone else in this category, he already has an Oscar at home, which probably rules him out.
4. Tom Hardy, The Revenant
For Him: Hardy has been doing solid work for a while, so it was just a matter of time before he finally got an Oscar nomination. Because of his already impressive resume, he could just jump to overdue, and win. Plus, they really like the film – and he arguably has more dialogue than DiCaprio, and is more impressive.
Against Him: He was kind of a surprise nominee – after spending much of the year as a sight unseen frontrunner, once it was seen, he didn’t show up nearly as often as people thought he would. The nomination will be award enough – and will make him “overdue” next time he gets nominated.
3. Mark Ruffalo, SpotlightFor Him: After going quite a long time getting no Academy love, he has turned into an Academy favorite in the past few years – this is his third nomination afterall. He fought off tough internal competition to score the nomination, and it’s practically a lead role, which never really hurts in these categories. Plus, they obviously love the film, and if it’s going to win the Best Picture Oscar – and it might – a win for him wouldn’t be out of the question.
Against Him: He really needed a win somewhere along the way to really put pressure on the two frontrunners, and he never got it. He is quickly entering the phase where he’s overdue, and a win becomes inevitable – but he’s not quite there yet.
2.Mark Rylance, Bridge of SpiesFor Him: For much of the season, he was probably the frontrunner – with the Spotlight guys fighting it out to see if anyone could get ahead, and no one else really making a case. Even those who don’t much like Bridge of Spies – or think it’s dull – seem to loved Rylance in it. He is precisely the type of well-respected, British character actor who they love to give a prize to here. If they’re worried about The Expendables 4 being advertised as starring Oscar winner Sylvestor Stallone, he’s their man.
Against Him: He lost momentum down the home stretch, as Stallone started winning everything in site in terms of the major awards. The lack of passion for the film may just end up sucking votes to other contenders. As well respected as he is, he isn’t beloved by the Academy.
1. Sylvester Stallone, CreedFor Him: He has been in the industry for 40 years now – and that type of longevity automatically gets you respect, even if he often hasn’t been making “Oscar” type movies. His work in Creed took his most legendary, larger than life character and made him human again. You cannot help but think that this role will resonate with the older Academy.
Against Him: They didn’t love the film, which is why his was the only nomination. They already got criticized for only nominating the white guy from the movie, will the controversy make it harder from him to win? He isn’t exactly beloved by everyone.
Who Will Win: Sylvestor Stallone, Creed. It is a tight race – I wouldn’t be shocked to see Rylance win, and a Ruffalo upset isn’t out of the question. Still, I think Stallone holds off all comers, and wins it.Who Should Win: Mark Rylance, Bridge of Spies Nothing against Stallone – who will be a worthy winner – but Rylance is an absolute delight in Bridge of Spies – a sympathetic, hilarious performance that makes the whole movie.
Least of the Nominees: Christian Bale, The Big Short. Really? I could think of a few actors in the same movie I would have nominated over Bale.
Best Supporting Actress5. Rachel McAdams, Spotlight
For Her: They obviously loved the movie – she was able to squeeze into this category, despite the fact that she missed many of the precursors. Supporting Actor may be too tough for Ruffalo to win, so perhaps they’ll reward the ensemble cast here.
Against Her: Her individual reviews weren’t stellar – fine, but not outstanding. She mainly got in because they loved the movie, not the performance, which isn’t the recipe to actually win this prize.
4. Kate Winslet, Steve JobsFor Her: She is an Oscar favorite – in play for the first time in 7 years, after finally winning her first Oscar for The Reader in 2008. She is at nomination #7, so a second win hardly seems out of the ordinary. She handles a lot of rapid fire dialogue, and does it with an accent.
Against Her: The film is hardly beloved – and neither is her performance, at least not enough to warrant a second win in a category where no one else has one yet.
3. Jennifer Jason Leigh, The Hateful Eight
For Her: She has been in the industry for 30 years, often doing stellar week, and amazingly she has never even been nominated before. She is the lone woman in a sea of men in the film – and the only one to receive a nomination. The last two Tarantino films won an acting Oscar after all.
Against Her: The Hateful Eight isn’t as loved as Inglorious Basterds or Django Unchained were – and I wonder how many Oscar members turned this off part way through. Charges of misogyny against the film doesn’t help.
2. Rooney Mara, CarolFor Her: She is a previous nominee (for The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo), and is basically a lead (which doesn’t hurt), and she already won one of the most prestigious prizes she can for the role – Best Actress at Cannes. It is a brilliant performance, and even if they didn’t nominate the film for Best Picture, it did pick up 6 noms, so it’s well respected.
Against Her: The performance is very quiet, very still and very subtle. That can get you nominated, but doesn’t often get you the win.
1. Alicia Vikander, The Danish GirlFor Her: She is this year’s Hollywood It Girl – showing up in half a dozen films, and getting good reviews for all of them. Even if you didn’t love her here, you may have loved her in Ex Machina (as I did), or something else. The love to award the young breakthrough star in this category, and this is a lead role. She cries beautifully.
Against Her: I don’t think they actually like the film all that much, given the nomination total, and all the advance buzz around it. Than again, there’s only one performance from a Best Picture nominee here – and that has no chance of winning.
Who Will Win: Alicia Vikander, The Danish Girl. This is where the smart money is, although Mara or even Leigh wouldn’t stun me at this point.
Who Should Win: Rooney Mara, Carol. I’m torn here, because Mara’s is the best performance of the nominees. It is also a lead performance, without doubt. If I cared more about category fraud, I’d go for Leigh. Since, I don’t, really, I’ll stick with Mara.
Least of the Nominees: Alicia Vikander, The Danish Girl. I would be delighted if Vikander had been nominated for Ex Machina. As she wasn’t, and was nominated for this instead, I’m torn. She’s fine in the movie – actually far and away the best thing in it. But the movie isn’t very good, and it hurts her as well.
Adapted screenplay5. Carol - Phyllis Nagy
4. Brooklyn - Nick Hornby
3. The Martian - Drew Goddard
2. Room - Emma Donoghue
1.The Big Short - Charles Randolph and Adam McKay
Who Will Win: The Big Short. Fighting off three other Best Picture nominees shouldn’t be hard for The Big Short – this is almost a sure thing.
Who Should Win: Carol. It is wonderful, subtle work – actually improving on the source material quite a bit.
Least of the Nominees: The Martian. I mean, the screenplay is quite good –it’s a strong field – but out of these five, it’s easily the least of them.
Original screenplay5. Straight Outta Compton - Jonathan Herman and Andrea Berloff and S. Leigh Savidge & Alan Wenkus
4. Bridge of Spies - Matt Charman and Ethan Coen & Joel Coen
3. Ex Machina - Alex Garland
2. Inside Out - Pete Docter, Meg LeFauve, Josh Cooley, Ronnie del Carmen
1.Spotlight - Josh Singer & Tom McCarthy
Who Will Win: Spotlight. Like The Big Short in adapted, this one is all but assured. It may or may not win Picture, but this one is assured.
Who Should Win: Inside Out. Stunning, brilliant, funny screenplay – the best of the year in any category.
Least of the Nominees: Straight Outta Compton. The screenplay is fine – but I find it quite odd that this was the only category where the film was nominated. The screenplay is very typical of the genre – solid work to be sure, but Oscar worthy?
Best Animated Film5. When Marnie Was There
4. Shaun the Sheep Movie
3. Boy and the World
1. Inside Out
Who Will Win: Inside Out. Pixar wins this even when they don’t make masterpieces. Inside Out is a masterpiece. This isn’t close.
Who Should Win: Insie Out. In almost any other year, Anomalisa would be an easy choice. But not this year – Inside Out was the year’s best film.
Least of the Nominees: When Marnie Was There. To be fair, I haven’t seen Boy and the World yet, but of the four I have seen, When Marnie Was There is the weakest – and I still quite liked it.
Best Documentary5. What Happened, Miss Simone?
4. Winter on Fire: Ukraine’s Fight for Freedom
3. Cartel Land
2. The Look of Silence
Who Will Win: Amy. Amy is shockingly won pretty much everything it could this season, and that probably isn’t going to stop at the Oscars. They’ve gone with showbiz films more and more often in the past few years – so unless What Happened, Miss Simone splits the vote, allowing something else to sneak in – or the Academy feels the need to make-up for the fact that they didn’t give Joshua Oppenheimer the Oscar for The Act of Killing, and give it to the sequel, The Look of Silence, Amy wins this one as well.
Who Should Win: The Look of Silence. One of the greatest documetaries of recent years – stunning, heartbreaking and utterly brilliant. Not even close to me – and I really like Amy and Cartel Land.
Least of the Nominees: What Happened, Miss Simone?. I still haven’t gotten around to Winter on Fire – but I wasn’t overly impressed with What Happened, Miss Simone? – especially in a year with some many great showbiz docs this year.
Best Foreign Language Film5. Embrace of the Serpent - Colombia
4. Theeb - Jordan
3. A War - Denmark
2. Mustang - France
1. Son of Saul - Hungary
Who Will Win: Son of Saul. It really is hard to tell, when you’ve only seen two of the nominees – but Son of Saul has dominated this category this year, so you have to assume it will win, right? On the other hand, this category often throws you some curveballs, so who knows.
Who Should Win: Mustang. I loved Son of Saul – but when I caught up with Mustang (late), I think I loved it even more. It’s close though.
Least of the Nominees: I’ve loved both of the nominees I have seen, so I’ll abstain here.
Best Cinematography5. The Hateful Eight - Robert Richardson
4. Carol - Ed Lachman
3. Sicario - Roger Deakins
2. Mad Max: Fury Road - John Seale
1. The Revenant - Emmanuel Lubezki
Who Will Win: The Revenant. Emmanuel Lubezki will almost certainly win his third straight Oscar, and even if I don’t think any of his Oscar work reaches the height of his work on Children of Men, The New World or The Tree of Life, he certainly is one of the very best in his field – and the cinematography is the one area of The Revenant I don’t have a problem with.
Who Should Win: Carol. Lachman is a genius – every bit as good as Lubezki – and he’s never won. The work on Carol isn’t as showy as The Revenant – but it’s the years best.
Least of the Nominees: Sicario. It pains me to say this – because Roger Deakins is a cinematography God, and he’s raked up 14 nominations without a win, and his work on Sicario is legitimately great. But of the five nominees – which may be the strongest bunch of nominees of the year – he’s would rank fifth for me.
Best Film Editing5. Star Wars: The Force Awakens
3. The Revenant
2. The Big Short
1. Mad Max: Fury Road
Who Will Win: Mad Max: Fury Road. Really, I can make a case for anything by Star Wars winning here. This will be an early bellweather for the rest of the night – if Mad Max or The Revenant win, than The Revenant wins Best Picture. If The Big Short or Spotlight pull it off, they could easily win Best Picture.
Who Should Win: Mad Max: Fury Road. It truly is amazing work – keeping up the propulsive tempo for two hours, and crafting the best action sequences in recent memory, it is masterful work.
Least of the Nominees: The Revenant. Sorry, but this film needed more editing. I know that’s not precisely what this movie is for, but still, as well constructed as it is, it’s the least of the five.
Best Original Score5. Sicario - Jóhann Jóhannsson
4. Bridge of Spies - Thomas Newman
3. Carol - Carter Burwell
2. Star Wars: The Force Awakens - John Williams
1. The Hateful Eight - Ennio Morricone
Who Will Win: The Hateful Eight. You could probably make a case here for any of them – Johannsson, doing great work for the second straight year, Newman, the oldtimer who keeps getting nominated and not winning, Burwell who has been doing great work for years, and finally got his first nom, Williams, the most nominated composer in history, for one last ride. Still, I think another oldtimer, Ennio Morricone, a legend in the field, will win his first competitive Oscar (he won a lifetime achievement one a few years ago).
Who Should Win: The Hateful Eight. Truly, it is a remarkable score – even those who hate the movie, love the music.
Least of the Nominees: Bridge of Spies. Spielberg not working with Williams is weird – and although Newman was a solid replacement, it is easily the least memorable of the nominees.
Best Costume Design5. The Revenant
4. The Danish Girl
2. Mad Max: Fury Road
Who Will Win: Cinderella. I think you could make a case for anything but The Revenant winning this one – but history tells us they like pretty dresses more than anything else, and that’s Cinderella. There’s a bonus that they are actually great, and Sandy Powell did amazing work on Carol as well, so it’s hard to argue she doesn’t deserve it.
Who Should Win: Carol. Sandy Powell does deserve the Oscar – for her other nomination this year though.
Least of the Nominees: The Danish Girl. Is it good work? Sure – does it deserve to be here instead of say Brooklyn or The Hateful Eight? No, no it doesn’t.
Makeup & Hair Styling3. The 100-Year-Old Man Who Climbed out the Window and Disappeared
2. The Revenant
1. Mad Max: Fury Road
Who Will Win: Mad Max: Fury Road. A head to head battle between Mad Max an The Revenant – that could go either way. My guess is that the exaggerated work on Mad Max beats the more realistic work on The Revenant – but it could go either way.
Who Should Win: Mad Max: Fury Road. Come on, it’s this, right?
Least of the Nominees: ? The work on both the frontrunners is excellent, and I never did see The 100-Year Old Man Who Climbed Out the Window and Disappeared, so I’ll abstain.
Original Song5. Racing Extinction - Manta Ray
4. Fifty Shades of Grey - Earned It
3. Spectre – Writing’s on the Wall
2. Youth – Simple Song # 3
1. The Hunting Ground - Til It Happens To You
Who Will Win: The Hunting Ground – Til It Happens To You. I spent most of Oscar season thinking that Simple Song #3 had this – it’s a great song, and the entire movie leads to it for the best moment in the film. Yet. The Academy didn’t really like the movie did they – and Lady Gaga has been working it. It helps that Til It Happens To You is actually a very good song
Who Should Win: Youth – Simple Song #3. I liked, but didn’t love Youth – but this song is the perfect way to end the film – and is the best of not a very good lot of nominees.
Least of the Nominees: Spectre – Writing’s on the Wall. True, if I had to listen to that Racing Extinction song as often as I had to listen to Writing’s on the Wall, it could overtake it. But this is a bad song – a very bad song. Considering that the Academy spent decades basically ignoring Bond themes, why the hell the went with this, I’ll never know. Skyfall was a great song. This one sucks.
Best Production Design5. The Danish Girl
4. Bridge of Spies
3. The Martian
2. The Revenant
1. Mad Max: Fury Road
Who Will Win: Mad Max: Fury Road. I really don’t think the other nominees are flashy enough to win this – which normally I hate (Flashy doesn’t mean great), but here it benefits Mad Max, so I’m good.
Who Should Win: Mad Max: Fury Road. Was their more creative production design among the nominees? No.
Least of the Nominees: The Danish Girl. Yawn.
Best Sound Editing5. Sicario
4. The Martian
3. Star Wars: The Force Awakens
2. The Revenant
1. Mad Max: Fury Road
Who Will Win: Mad Max: Fury Road. A tight two way race between Mad Max and The Revenant – with a possible Star Wars spoiler. I’ll go with Mad Max but it will be close .
Who Should Win: Mad Max: Fury Road. I think it wins, by a hair – my own feelings are that it should win easily.
Least of the Nominees: The Martian. Don’t think it’s bad work in any way. Just not sure it’s as good as the rest.
Best Sound Mixing5. Bridge of Spies
4. The Martian
3. Star Wars: The Force Awakens
2. Mad Max: Fury Road
1. The Revenant
Who Will Win: The Revenant. I said above the sound awards are probably a two way race between Mad Max and The Revenant – I went with Mad Max there, so I’ll choose The Revenant here. How’s that for fancy predicting? (If you really want to know why, I think the Mad Max has more obviously created sound effects – which is in the other category, so I gave it the edge there).
Who Should Win: Mad Max: Fury Road. The sound work is amazing in Mad Max – and although there was a lot of great sound work this year in unexpected places (a foreign film like Son of Saul, a documentary like Kurt Cobain: Montage of Heck) – the academy went boring, meaning Mad Max should win in a cakewalk.
Least of the Nominees: Bridge of Spies. It really is fine work – but I’m not quite sure what landed it the Oscar nomination over anything else.
Best Visual Effects5. Ex Machina
4. The Martian
3. The Revenant
2. Mad Max: Fury Road
1. Star Wars: The Force Awakens
Who Will Win: Star Wars: The Force Awakens – I cannot imagine that the Academy is going to let Star Wars go home empty handed, so it probably takes this one – one of the few tech prizes not to go to Mad Max or The Revenant, although either could win here – often the Academy will go for a Best Picture nominee over a non-nominee in the tech races.
Who Should Win: Mad Max: Fury Road. I do love that Fury Road employed a lot of practicaly effects – which is great – and their use of CGI (and there is a lot) is also wonderful. I love the lower key, smaller budgeted work on Ex Machina as well, but Mad Max would get my vote.
Least of the Nominees: The Martian. Another category where I don’t dislike any of the nominees – it’s fine work all around, and perhaps would be my lineup as well. The Martian is a step back from The Revenant, but it’s close.
Best motion picture of the year: The Revenant
Best Director: Alejandro G. Innaritu, The Revenant
Best Actor: Leonardo DiCaprio, The Revenant
Best Actress: Brie Larson, Room
Best Supporting Actor: Sylvester Stallone, Creed
Best Supporting Actress: Alicia Vikander, The Danish Girl
Adapted screenplay: The Big Short - Charles Randolph and Adam McKay
Original screenplay: Spotlight - Josh Singer & Tom McCarthy
Best Animated Film: Inside Out
Best Documentary: Amy
Best Foreign Language Film: Son of Saul - Hungary
Best Cinematography: The Revenant Emmanuel Lubezki
Best Film Editing: The Big Short
Best Original Score: The Hateful Eight - Ennio Morricone
Best Costume Design: Cinderella
Makeup & Hair Styling: Mad Max: Fury Road
Original Song: The Hunting Ground - Til It Happens To You
Best Production Design: Mad Max: Fury Road
Best Sound Editing: Mad Max: Fury Road
Best Sound Mixing: The Revenant
Best Visual Effects: Star Wars: The Force Awakens