Wednesday, November 13, 2013

Movie Review: Blue is the Warmest Color

Blue is the Warmest Color
Directed by: Abdellatif Kechiche.
Written by: Abdellatif Kechiche & Ghalia Lacroix based on the graphic novel by Julie Maroh.
Starring: Adèle Exarchopoulos (Adèle), Léa Seydoux (Emma), Salim Kechiouche (Samir), Aurélien Recoing (Le père d'Adèle), Catherine Salée (La mère d'Adèle), Benjamin Siksou (Antoine), Mona Walravens (Lise), Alma Jodorowsky (Béatrice), Jérémie Laheurte (Thomas), Anne Loiret (La mère d'Emma), Benoît Pilot (Le beau-père d'Emma), Sandor Funtek (Valentin), Fanny Maurin (Amélie), Maelys Cabezon (Laetitia).
 
Blue is the Warmest Color has become one of the most talked about films of the year for three reasons – first, because it won the Palme D’or, which is arguably the most prestigious prize in film, second because of the nasty feud between director Abdellatif Kechiche and star Lea Seydoux (and to a lesser extent, Adele Exarchopoulos) – which doesn’t interest me very much, so this will be the last time I mention it – and third because it features graphic, extended lesbian sex scenes. Coming out of Cannes, all I read about were those sex scenes, which is odd, because the movie is three hours long, and I would say less than 30 minutes (probably significantly less, although I didn’t bring a stop watch) is taken up with those scenes. Yes, they are memorable and erotic – and yes, like pretty much all movie sex scenes, I don’t think they are particularly realistic, but I don’t really think they have to be. Most of the movie is a coming of age film – a film about a sexually confused young woman in the process of discovering who she is – emotionally and sexually, a process that the movie makes clear hasn’t ended when the movie does. The movie has some problems – but overall I found it a perceptive, insightful and emotionally charged story, that is brilliantly acted by the two leads.

The movie stars Adele Exarchopoulos as Adele – a junior in high school, who hangs out with the popular crowd of beautiful, but bitchy, teenage girls. Based on their talk, they are all sexually experienced – but Adele remains mainly quiet on the subject, even when they tease her about a boy a year older – Thomas (Jeremie Laheurte) who is clearly making eyes at her. She dates Thomas for a while – even sleeps with him in the movie’s first sex scene – but the spark just isn’t there. It is there when she locks eyes with Emma (Lea Seydoux) – first on the street, and later when she follows her to a lesbian bar. The attraction is immediate and strong – all their interactions are charged with sexual energy, well before the now infamous sex scenes. The movie charts their relationship over a number of years – first love blossoming, and then, inevitably, turning sour, even if that love and attraction is still there.

Exarchopoulos is wonderful in the movie. She plays a young girl who really doesn’t know who she is – she is scattered and messy, like the beautiful mess of hair she cannot seem to do anything with it, except let it cascade over her face. She is a girl of big appetites – Kechiche delights in watching her eat, which she does more often than Brad Pitt does in any of his films. She is a confused girl, who sometimes acts impulsively, and does things that end up hurting others, yet she never loses our empathy – she doesn’t mean to hurt others, but she behaves like a teenage girl, which she is, and that sometimes happens. Seydoux is equally great as the older Emma – unlike Adele, she has no confusion over who she is, or what she wants. She is an artist, and completely comfortable in her own skin – and projects the kind of confidence that Adele admires – although she can be thoughtless as well. There is a reason that for the first time ever the Steven Spielberg led Cannes Jury insisted these two actresses share the Palme D’or with the director – they are two of the very best performances of the year.

The movie itself is not quite as good as they are. At three hours, it is a little too long – especially in the third hour, which is tougher to watch because watching things fall apart is more painful that watching love bloom. Every scene in the movie – including the sex scenes – is overlong, which I think is kind of the point, but also does begin to drag a little as it continues. When Kechiche says there is a longer cut of the movie, I have no trouble believing him – there are plot threads that are left dangling, like what became of all of Adele’s high school friends the movie spends so much time with in the first hour, establishes some of their homophobia, and then abandons, and whether or not Adele ever “comes out” to her family – there are twin scenes, where each girl brings the other to her parents for dinner – Emma’s parents know, and Adele’s clearly do not as the women lie to them, yet Adele clearly lives with Emma later. Do they think they’re just roommates? Perhaps there are cut scenes that illuminate these issues – and perhaps Kechiche was right to cut them, but they stood out to me (and there are a few others).

I guess I have to say something about the sex scenes in the movie – and the charge that they represent the male gaze on behalf of Kechiche. I find it impossible to refute the charge that Kechiche’s camera is clearly in love with Exarchopoulos – her face, seen in close-up a lot, is always loving framed, and there are numerous shots where Kechiche equally lovingly frames her ass (it is, it must be said, a very nice ass). The sex scenes are extended and graphic, watching these two beautiful actresses in the throes of ecstasy. Yes, to a certain extent, the male gaze is on full display in Blue is the Warmest Color. Yet the sex scenes do actually serve a larger purpose in the movie – especially Adele’s disappointing experience to Thomas and that extended, passionate first scene with Emma – that establish better than any dialogue could the difference between Adele’s two lovers, and how she feels about them. Besides, is it inherently wrong to make a movie about sex that is actually erotic and sexy? Do movie sex scenes ever portray what actual sex is really like, or do they all somewhat exaggerate? Kechiche and his camera may feel a degree of lust towards Exarchopoulos, but given the context of the movie, it’s feels appropriate, not exploitive.

Blue is the Warmest Color is not quite the masterpiece its biggest supporters believe it to be – but I also don’t feel it’s as perverted as its detractors think it is. At its heart, it’s a wonderful story of a young woman discovering who she is – and where her place in the world is. Even with the sex scenes and the NC-17 rating in the States, I think the movie is appropriate for teenagers – in fact, I think they’ll get more out of the film than anyone else will. Many of them will undoubtedly see a little of themselves in Adele.

Movie Review: Dallas Buyers Club

Dallas Buyers Club
Directed by: Jean-Marc Vallée.
Written by: Craig Borten & Melisa Wallack.
Starring: Matthew McConaughey (Ron Woodroof), Jared Leto (Rayon), Jennifer Garner (Dr. Eve Saks), Denis O'Hare (Dr. Savari), Steve Zahn (Police Officer), Dallas Roberts (David Wayne), Kevin Rankin (T.J.), Griffin Dunne (Doctor Vas), Michael O’Neal (Richard Barkley).
 
Dallas Buyers Club tells the remarkable true story (probably heavily fictionalized, but whatever) of Ron Woodroof – a homophobic Texas man, who works an electrician and hangs out at rodeos, who discovers in 1985 that through his womanizing, he has contracted HIV. At the time, many assumed only gay men and drug users got HIV (a stereotype that sadly some still believe). The doctors give Ron 30 days to live – and yet he lives for years after his diagnosis – and does so not by listening to his doctors, but by ignoring them. They won’t give him the drugs he needs – they are not approved by the FDA yet – so he finds other ways to get them – and when that supply runs dry, he finds other drugs and supplements to help him survive. Since these drugs and supplements are not approved by the FDA he has to smuggle them into the country, and is at constant risk of their being confiscated. Never one to miss a chance at making money, he steals an idea from “some queens” in New York – and opens a Buyers Club in Dallas. He won’t sell its members the non-FDA approved stuff, but he will sell them a membership to the club, and then give them everything they need.

Woodruff is played by Matthew McConaughey in another great performance. After years of making empty headed romcoms and thrillers – years I mainly spent thinking McConaughey was as empty as the characters he played – he has now amassed a remarkable string of quality movies and performances in a row – The Lincoln Lawyer, Bernie, Magic Mike, The Paperboy, Killer Joe, Mud and now this. In a few short years, he’s gone from one of my least favorite actors to one of my favorites working today. McConaughey lost a lot of weight to play Woodruff – but it wasn’t (just) to make him seem sicker – he’s as skinny at the beginning (and not alarmed by it) as he is at the end. He is not all skin and bones – but wiry and tough. This is the type of role that McConaughey excels at – it still gives him a chance to exude his undeniable Southern charm, and makes the most of its comic gifts (this is a surprisingly funny movie, given its subject matter). It’s deeper than that as well, as McConaughey makes Woodruff’s pain and frustration real – he doesn’t want to die, but no one will help him stay alive, so he has to help himself. It may not be the best performance McConaughey has ever given (for me, that would be Killer Joe or Mud) – but it’s close, and it elevates the whole movie.

Also elevating movie is the performance by Jared Leto as Rayon, a transvestite, who helps Ron connect with his mainly gay clientele. Leto was once a star on the rise, who slowed down his acting career to concentrate on his music (I won’t tell you what I think of his band 30 Seconds to Mars because that wouldn’t be very nice). Acting for the first time in 4 years, Leto delivers a great performance as Rayon. Often, when an actor plays a transvestite, it’s little more than a stunt – but Leto so inhabits the character, makes Rayon’s every move, gesture and line seem completely natural, that it barely even registers you’re watching Leto – until the one, utterly heartbreaking, scene where he puts on a suit to go see his father. McConaughey and Leto both deliver great performances, and anchor the movie when it hits some rough patches – and there is more than one.

For one thing, the movie seems confused as to who the “villain” of the movie is – and why (I don’t think the movie needed a villain, but that’s Hollywood for you). At first, the doctors and the FDA are monsters for NOT giving people like Woodruff AZT, the drug they thought would cure or at least slow down the disease, and then they are monsters for ONLY giving patients AZT. The movie tries hard to make Dennis O’Hare’s doctor and Michael O’Neal’s FDA agent into the villains of the movie – but the reality is that the bureaucracy is the real villain – it moves too slowly for people in crisis – and the reality is far more complex than the movie lets on (see the excellent documentary How to Survive a Plague from last year for more details). Of course, you cannot make a bureaucracy a villain, so the film tries to make human an entire system – and while it’s not quite as simplistic as a movie like The Help blaming all of Southern racism on Bryce Dallas Howard’s housewife, it isn’t that far off either. The movie does try and point out that the entire medical community isn’t as unfeeling as these two – they make Jennifer Garner’s Dr. Eve Saks into a sympathetic character – but she’s also a rather one note character. Garner’s naturally sympathetic eyes give the character more weight than the screenplay does – but that only goes so far.

These flaws (and a few others, like a thankfully short segment where Woodruff crisscrossed the globe in a series of disguises to bring back more and better drugs, that wouldn’t feel out of place in an Ocean’s 11 movie) are not fatal though. The movie never overdoses on sentimentality like many films of its ilk would (particularly in the way it handles death) and while Woodruff certainly changes his attitude throughout the film towards gay people, he never fully lets go of those prejudices either – nor does the movie make any attempt to make Woodruff completely sanitized either – he remains a womanizer, in what limited capacity he can – and a good ol’boy, drunken redneck – although McConaughey makes him into one so charming, we hardly care. Directed by Canadian Jean-Marc Vallee (C.R.A.Z.Y., the under seen Café de Flore), Dallas Buyers Club is a good movie about the AIDS crisis, elevated because of two great performances. Yes, it may be more than a little strange that one of the only movies Hollywood has made about the AIDS crisis has a straight man as its protagonist – but Woodruff’s story is more than enough to support a movie, and deserves to be told.

Movie Review: Thor: The Dark World

Thor: The Dark World
Directed by: Alan Taylor.
Written by: Christopher Yost and Christopher Markus & Stephen McFeely and Don Payne and Robert Rodat based on the comic book by Stan Lee and Larry Lieber and Jack Kirby.
Starring: Chris Hemsworth (Thor), Natalie Portman (Jane Foster), Tom Hiddleston (Loki), Anthony Hopkins (Odin), Christopher Eccleston (Malekith), Jaimie Alexander (Sif), Zachary Levi (Fandral), Ray Stevenson (Volstagg), Tadanobu Asano (Hogun), Idris Elba (Heimdall), Rene Russo (Frigga), Adewale Akinnuoye-Agbaje (Algrim / Kurse), Kat Dennings (Darcy Lewis), Stellan Skarsgård (Erik Selvig), Alice Krige (Eir), Clive Russell (Tyr), Jonathan Howard (Ian Boothby).
One of the biggest strengths of the Marvel films surrounding The Avengers is also one of its limitations – that is, there is a comforting sameness about the 8 films made so far. So far, only one director (Jon Favreau) has directed more than one of the films (Iron Man and Iron Man 2), and yet visually, almost all of the films feel the same. Story wise, they also feel similar – there is always a villain who the hero or heroes has to confront, with the fate of the world hanging in the balance – and each of the plots connects to the other ones. At their worst (Iron Man 2), the films feel more like trailers for other films in the series. The series is always looking forward – to the next film or films in the series. The series is certainly ambitious – I cannot think of another series of this scale that has even attempted something quite so large – and for the most part, the quality of the series has been remarkably consistent. Yet, by always focusing on the large arc of the series as a whole, and having the same basic visual design for each film no matter who the hero is, it does somewhat diminish each of the characters – who after all, are remarkably different. One of the reasons I appreciated the admittedly not great, but still good, The Wolverine from this past summer was that it was a different superhero movie – a standalone (aside from the post trailer tease of Days of Future Past) – and allowed Wolverine to have an adventure apart from the series, and one where the fate of the world doesn’t hang in the balance – the stakes are smaller, but also slightly more intimate.

All of this is a very long lead into Thor: The Dark World, the second standalone Thor film, and the third featuring Chris Hemsworth as Thor and Tom Hiddleston as his maniacal brother Loki. Like the other films in the series, the film is well made – this time by TV vet Alan Taylor – and is, for the most part, incredibly entertaining. The role of Thor fits Hemsworth like a glove – he’s beefy and charming, and has some excellent comic timing, which serves Thor well when he’s stranded on earth as a fish out of water (which, regrettably, isn’t for very long this time). Hiddleston is even better as Loki – in fact, I think this is my favorite of his three appearances in the series so far. Loki, now trapped in a dungeon below Asgard, has become even more cynical and petulant – he already lost everything, so now he’s decided to be a dick about it – which makes him incredibly fun to watch. It’s also good to see Natalie Portman back as Dr. Jane Foster, Thor’s human love interest, and this time the tables are turned – with her spending most of her time, in his world, and not quite fitting in. Portman brings a natural intelligence to her role, which somewhat offsets the fact that the movie doesn’t think of much for her to do, except be a damsel in distress, that Thor has to save – repeatedly. Of course, the film also brings back Anthony Hopkins – who is a natural fit for Odin – and even gives Rene Russo slightly more to do this time around as his wife, Frigga.

The story has something to do with long dormant Dark Elves, led by Malekith (Christopher Eccleston – a talented actor wasted under all sorts of makeup and CGI) – who was defeated by Odin’s father thousands of years ago, but is awoken when Jane discovers his weapon – the Aether – that he intends to use when the Nine Realms come into alignment for the first time in 5,000 years (or something like that). Truthfully, I didn’t much care for the specifics of Malekith’s plot – and neither I think does the movie, who just wants to have a series of action sequences where the seemingly invincible Thor is up against someone who actually stands a chance of beating him (although the mid-credits sequence, which I won’t spoil, does seem to indicate the series is not done with the Aether quite yet).

The movie is fast paced and entertaining – it contains good action set pieces and CGI work – and delivers what fans of the series want. I have ceased to be surprised by the series – you know the arc when you walk into the theater, and the films never really deviate from them – but that is not to say there is not fun to be had watching them. Seeing as how the series is going to continue for the foreseeable future, personally, I would prefer them to bring in more ambitious directors and writers, and let them off the reigns a little bit – explore the characters in more interesting ways. But that involves more risk than we’ll probably see from the series. Thor: The Dark World delivers what it promises – and I certainly had fun watching it. I just wish the series was slightly less predictable.

Movie Review: The Broken Circle Breakdown

The Broken Circle Breakdown
Directed by: Felix Van Groeningen.
Written by: Carl Joose and Felix Van Groeningen based on the play by  Johan Heldenbergh and Mieke Dobbels.
Starring: Veerle Baetens (Elise Vandevelde), Johan Heldenbergh (Didier Bontinck), Nell Cattrysse (Maybelle), Geert Van Rampelberg (William), Nils De Caster (Jock), Robbie Cleiren (Jimmy), Bert Huysentruyt (Jef), Jan Bijvoet (Koen), Blanka Heirman (Denise).

The Broken Circle Breakdown is a movie that seems like it should be an overly sentimental, hackneyed tearjerker, and yet somehow manages not to be. This is a movie after all that hinges on a child with cancer – and I cannot think of another example of a film that treats a child with cancer with the kind of respect that this film does. It doesn’t beat you over the head with its misery, although it doesn’t soft peddle it either. Besides, there is a lot more going on in The Broken Circle Breakdown than just a child with cancer – not least of which is the wonderful bluegrass music that runs through the entire film. You’d probably be right to skip a Hollywood version of the same story told here, but this Belgian film is beautifully well done.

The story cycles backs and forth in time, gradually moving further in out in all directions. It tells the story of Didier (Johan Heldenbergh), a bluegrass musician, and his relationship and eventual marriage to Elise (Veerle Baetens), a tattoo artist, who uses her body as a walking advertisement for her work, as well as a chronicle of her love life. The two begin dating, and eventually, Didier draws Elise into his bluegrass band as a co-lead vocalist. They have a beautiful daughter – Maybelle (Nell Cattrysse) – and life seems good, until of course, Maybelle is diagnosed with cancer, and they have to go through a series of painful, ultimately futile, procedures.

This sounds like a heavy slog of a film, yet while the going isn’t easy, the film is more than just a parade of misery. The structure helps quite a bit – being able to move back and forth in time allows director Felix Van Groeningen not to pile all the cancer sequences on top of each other. Instead, he is able to show the connection slowly building between Didier and Elise – both an on-stage chemistry, and an undeniable sexual chemistry as well. Telling the story in this way does give even these early scenes a melancholy feel – we know where this is all leading to – but it’s one that works for the movie. The music also grows progressively darker as the movie progresses – these are not just musical interludes for the sake of musical interludes, but rather they advance the story, and illuminate the characters – perhaps nowhere more so than when the pair sing “If I Needed You”, which is a heartbreaking moment, as the answer becomes clear.

The movie makes a few missteps in its later stages. Up until the final act, the film had been subtly and effectively showing the difference between how Didier and Elise react when the inevitable comes – her wanting more and more to have faith – to believe in something beyond – and him being a more and more committed atheist. When the film was subtle about these changes, and the couple’s drifting apart, it was effective – when it brings it to the forefront – and has the characters start shouting at each other, and others, their effectiveness wanes considerably.

Still, even when The Broken Circle Breakdown makes some missteps, two elements keep it watchable – the first being the music, and the second being the performances. Performances in a movie like this are tricky, as you have to show the character evolving over such a long period of time, but only have a few moments to do so – both Heldenbergh and especially Baetens ground the movie at all times - she has the advantage of not being as overwritten as Didier is at times, and having the more heartbreaking finale, and she makes the most of it. And special mention should be made of little Nell Cattrysse as Maybelle – I’m never quite sure with child actors if the director or the children themselves should get the most credit – and I don’t think it really matters – but Cattrysse avoids most of the mawkish pitfalls that many child actors fall into when they are playing someone sick. She remains resolutely a child – a scared one, but one who loves her mommy and daddy, and just wants everything to be okay. Her performance is all the more heartbreaking because it doesn’t give us the BIG moments we expect her to get.

The Broken Circle Breakdown is a movie, like John Carney’s Once, that uses music to expand our understanding of the characters and the plot – and deepen our relationship with them. This is not an easy thing to do – many musicals fail completely, which is why many music numbers in films feel feel unnecessary. Here, they are essential. It’s a difficult thing to pull off – but The Broken Circle Breakdown does so beautifully.

Movie Review: Great Expectations

Great Expectations
Directed by: Mike Newell.
Written by: David Nicholls based on the novel by Charles Dickens.
Starring: Helena Bonham Carter (Miss Havisham), Ralph Fiennes (Magwitch), Jason Flemyng (Joe Gargery), Jeremy Irvine (Pip), Holliday Grainger (Estella), Robbie Coltrane (Mr. Jaggers), Sally Hawkins (Mrs. Joe), Ewen Bremner (Wemmick), Olly Alexander (Herbert Pocket), Ben Lloyd-Hughes (Bentley Drummle), Helena Barlow (Young Estella), Toby Irvine (Young Pip).

I have no idea how many screen versions of Charles Dickens’ Great Expectations have been made, or even how many of those versions I’ve seen – but I do know I’ve seen quite a few. The ones that stand out in my mind are David Lean’s classic 1946 version, which will probably always be the definitive version, a BBC version that I had to sit through in 8th grade that bored me to tears at the time (and why the hell we watched it remains a mystery to me, since we never read the book) and Alfonso Cuaron’s 1998 version, which brought the story to modern times, which was visually astounding, although dramatically had mixed results. When you adapt a book as well-known as Great Expectations that has already been adapted numerous times the pressure has to be on to try and go in some bold new direction with the material. This is probably why Roman Polanski’s Oliver Twist (2005) left so many disappointed – it was a simple a solid, respectable adaptation of the Dickens’ classic, and nothing more. The same can be said for Mike Newell’s version of Great Expectations. It certainly doesn’t invent the wheel here, it really brings nothing new or exciting in its interpretation of the Dickens’ classic – but it is a solid, respectful, well-acted and well-made version of the story we know so well. 

Young Pip (Toby Irvine) is mourning the loss of his family in the graveyard when he meets an escaped convict (Ralph Fiennes), who when he discovers Pip is being raised by the blacksmith, demands he show up the next morning with tools that will cut him free of the shackles – which he does. And even though the convict is later caught – right before Pip’s eyes – neither he nor Pip reveal that they met each other before. Then Pip comes to the attention of Miss Havisham – a woman living in the past, who keeps her magnificent house in the same décor as her wedding day, when she was jilted, and refuses to change out of her wedding dress. She is raising young Estella (Helena Barlow) – and wants Pip for a playmate for her. What she really wants though is to teach Estella to be a heartless shrew – a beautiful woman, who will break the hearts of men, just like hers was broken. And Pip is to be the first test. And when Miss Havisham later cruelly dismisses Pip, and he can no longer see Estella, his heart truly is broken. Years pass, and Pip is training as an apprentice to his brother in law Joe (Jason Flemyng), the blacksmith, when a lawyer named Jaggers (Robbie Coltrane) shows up at their door. It seems Pip has come into some money – the source of which is to remain anonymous – and he is to go to London and become a “gentleman”.  Pip sees this as his chance to get Estella, once and for all – and quickly, and cruelly, leaves Joe behind.

This version of Great Expectations is pretty much what you would expect. It is a triumph of production design. Miss Havisham’s crumbling mansion is beautifully rendered, and the streets of London are muddier than in most other versions you’ve seen. Newell does underline the cruelty in the story – about how both Pip and Estella are essentially abused children, whose lives are forever warped because of the adults in their lives – notably Miss Havisham – who so lost in her own wounds, cruelly lashes out at the children, and by extension the world.

And the performances are quite good as well. Helena Bonham Carter is a gifted actress, and a natural choice to play Miss Havisham – especially since in recent years, she has pretty much worked exclusively with her partner Tim Burton in bringing forth weird, strangely made up, cruel characters (or starring in the Harry Potter films, and acting as if she was still in a Burton film). Her Miss Havisham is not an object of pity in this version, but a cruelly dismissive woman – one who knows the heartbreak she is setting in motion, and quite simply doesn’t care. It is a fine performance by Bonham Carter – although I must say I wish she would play a normal character once in a while. She doesn’t have to take on every strange role does she? Ralph Fiennes is even better as the convict – especially in his early scenes, when caked with mud, he seems almost to be channeling Daniel Day-Lewis, and the terror he causes poor Pip is palpable. Jason Flemyng is the film’s most sympathetic character as poor Joe – who tries his best, and is really a hard-working, nice guy, who still gets screwed over. Adding color, mainly in the background, is Robbie Coltrane as the seemingly jovial Jaggers, Sally Hawkins as the shrill, comically abusive “Mrs. Joe”, Ewen Bremmer as Jaggers’ assistant and Olly Alexander as Pip’s friend Herbert. The supporting cast in the movie is superb – and helps to keep proceedings from bogging down.

Unfortunately, this version of Great Expectations suffers from some of the same problems that many do – essentially that the two apparent leads, Pip (played as an adult by Jeremy Irvine) and Estella (played by Holliday Grainger) seem rather dull compared to those around them. Pip is a little shit, who needs to learn a lesson – and he does – but his mooning after Estella doesn’t feel real. Perhaps that’s because as Estella, Grainger gives us nothing but her beauty to real feel anything for. She’s barely a character at all.

Yet despite this, I liked Mike Newell’s film. It is entertaining, superbly directed and designed, and for the most part wonderfully acted. Plus there is a reason why this story is so well known – it’s great – and I had no problem slipping back into this world originally created by Dickens, and brought to life in the movie. Does it add anything new to our understanding of the novel? Not really. But it’s a fine, respectable adaptation.

Note: I wrote this review based on a screening at the 2012 Toronto Film Festival – as far as I know, the film didn’t undergo any editing after that screening, but it still felt like something I should point out.

My Answer to the Latest Criticwire Survey Question: Videostore That Changed Your Life

Q: With Blockbuster Video closing its remaining stores in January, the video-store era is drawing to a close, but for most critics they were an essential part of learning to love movies. What was the video store that changed your life?

There are many video stores I could choose from that helped me learn to love movies. The chain store Videoscene had a location near my house – and I can still recall precisely what the store looked like, and what the VHS cases looked like, with their brightly colored stickers indicating what genre they were. It was here that my family rented new releases – including such formidable titles to me such as Pulp Fiction and Natural Born Killers. There was the Just New Releases near my high school, which I stopped at often during my five years there (no, I didn’t fail – Ontario at that time had 5 years of high school) – the staff there knew me well, and I could hang out there for an hour talking movies with them. There was Steve’s TV – which I didn’t start going to until I could drive, because it was the next town over. They had a wonderful deal on their older titles - $1 for 1 night – on a sliding scale, meaning you could get up to 10 titles for 10 nights for $10. I made my way through the AFI top 100 lists on those deals, especially during the summer months, where often I would only need 3 days to get through 10 titles. They had a great selection of older American movies – but not so much of foreign films, although I do know I got my first taste of foreign masters like Bergman, Fellini, Kurosawa and Bunuel from them – even if all they carried was Persona, 8 ½ , Seven Samurai and Belle de Jour.

The store I will go with though is Generation X in Waterloo, Ontario. Like Videoscene and Just New Releases above, it’s closed now (Steve’s TV is still going – but I haven’t been there in a while, and don’t know what their selection is like now). It was started by a student at one of the two Waterloo universities (I forget which now) after he graduated. He came up with the idea simply – when he needed to write a paper for class about Martin Scorsese, and discovered that there were a few titles that no store in the area had, he drove to Toronto to get them – and then decided that he would eventually open a store in Waterloo so other students didn’t have to do the same. Unlike Steve’s or the other stores, there was no package deal on older titles – it was $3.50 a night for older movies, $4.50 for new releases. But they had EVERYTHING. I fell in love with Kurosawa and Bergman, and they had everything that was available by both on VHS. This is also where I got everything by Woody Allen. And that’s just the tip of the iceberg. The store was staffed by young people – they were obviously partly inspired by Kevin Smith’s Clerks – they had printed sign in the window that told you the store opened at 11am daily – “When We’re Awake, No Guarantees” I knew if I wanted a specific title, and Generation X did not have it, than no one else would. I could also just go in and browse – and did so all the time, sometimes wandering around for an hour or more (I still have the same habit in video stores – I love getting lost in the aisles, and sometimes making impulsive decisions on what to rent that night). Throughout my last two years of high school, four years of college and one year post college when I lived in Waterloo, I’m not sure a full week every went by without me renting something for Generation X. Although it had been a few years since I’d been back, when I heard it was closing, it hit me hard.

I don’t go to Video stores much anymore – they don’t have a decent one in my town of Brantford since Blockbuster and Rogers both decided to close a few years ago, despite the odd fact they were both making money (Blockbuster Canada closed because Blockbuster America was trying to keep itself afloat). Neither store were great, but now we have nothing. To add insult to injury, while Americans have any number of great streaming services, Canada is woefully lacking in that area. Check out what you can get on Netflix America compared to Netflix Canada. It’s pathetic. And the number of movies Americans can get Day-And-Date is way greater than in Canada – I will finally get to see Blue Caprice this week, as it showed up on iTunes Canada – still waiting for Ain’t Them Bodies Saints and Short Term 12. The best video store I still go to is Bay Street Video in Toronto – which has an even larger selection than Generation X had back in the day. I still like to get lost there – although I don’t do it anywhere near as often as I used to.
 
Video stores are dying – most are dead already. It’s probable my two year daughter will never know what one is. But without them, I wouldn’t be the movie lover I am today.

Wednesday, November 6, 2013

Movie Review: The Wind Rises

The Wind Rises
Directed by: Hayao Miyazaki.
Written by: Hayao Miyazaki based on his comic.
Starring: Hideaki Anno (Jirô Horikoshi), Mirai Shida (Kayo Horikoshi), Jun Kunimura (Hattori), Hidetoshi Nishijima (Honjô), Miori Takimoto (Naoko Satomi), Masahiko Nishimura (Kurokawa), Mansai Nomura (Caproni), Steve Alpert (Kastrup), Shinobu Ôtake (Kurokawa's Wife), Morio Kazama (Satomi).

Hayao Miyazaki’s The Wind Rises is apparently the animation master’s final film. Yes, he’s said that before, but this time it’s likely true. At 72, he says he’s slowed down and that it took five years to make the film – and if he started one now, it would take even longer, and he may not finish. If this truly is his last film, than it is a fitting way for arguably the greatest director of animation in cinema history to end his career. The film certainly does feel like a final film – the type of film an aging master feels he simply has to make before he dies. The film may not quite be the masterpiece of Spirited Away (2002) or Princess Mononoke (1997) – but it’s still one of his best.

The movie is a heavily fictionalized biopic of Jiro Horikoshi – the visionary aeronautical engineer who helped push Japan to the forefront of airplane technology in the years leading up to WWII. The movie has already come under fire from some who think it is an apology for a man who designed instruments of death – while at the same time, it has come under attack from some in Japan for portraying its military in such a negative light (neither controversy seems to have affected attendance – in Japan, it’s already a huge hit). The first criticism is ridiculous. From the outset, the movie addresses the conflict between those who build planes – and those who use them. The film has a recurring set of dreams, involving Italian airplane designer Caproni, who tells Jiro that “planes are beautiful dreams” and warns against them being used as weapons. Throughout the movie, Jiro is thoroughly uninterested in the military use of his planes – at one point wanting to eliminate guns from his latest fighter to make it lighter, and give it the ability to movie quicker. The movie even ends with Jiro lamenting that none of his beautiful planes made it back from the war (with Caproni saying “there was nothing to come back to”). The second criticism is fairer – Miyazaki certainly doesn’t portray the Japanese military in a positive light (they are basically buffoons), and there are also disturbing elements referencing the thought police – but that’s part of his point in the movie. He has been openly critical of the current government’s plan to rebuild the Japanese military. It certainly didn’t bother me in the least.

The movie charts not  only the leaps in airplane technology spearheaded by Jiro, but also Japan’s transition into being a more modern country. One of the most gripping sequences in the movie happens near the beginning – where an earthquake leads to fires that destroy much of the country. And Japan is still a country where epidemics of TB were still commonplace. Through the course of the movie, the planes Jiro gets built become more modern – and are no longer pulled to the runway by oxen – and the country changes as well. Miyazaki doesn’t shy away from saying that not all these changes were for the better.

In addition to being a movie about planes, the film is also a gentle love story (some critics have already complained it’s too much Love Story for them – but screw the cynics). For much of the movie, Jiro seems lost in his dreams of flight – but then he meets a beautiful young woman (they are brought together by the wind – a recurring motif in the film). They love each other deeply – but she is ill, and he is driven by his work. And yet, they do not let these obstacles stop them. The love story, as obvious as it may be, gives the movie it’s emotional core.

Of course, as with any movie by Miyazaki, the animation in impeccable. In most of his other films, he has created strange mystical creatures, and fantastical worlds, but other than the dreams sequences, Miyazaki doesn’t create anything fantastical this time out. But that doesn’t mean the film isn’t a wonder to behold – it is, from the aforementioned earthquake, to the flying sequences (both real, and in the dream world), and even the quieter moments, Miyazaki’s film is a wonder to behold from start to finish.

In North America, animation is still mainly seen as kids’ stuff. In the past few years, even the consistently excellent Pixar has faltered a little bit, meaning it’s been a few years since I saw an animated film I thought was truly wonderful. While The Wind Rises isn’t quite up to the level of the best Miyazaki has ever made – it’s pretty close. It is easily the best animated film I’ve seen in a number of years – and a fitting way for Miyazaki to end his career.

Note: This review is based on a screening at TIFF 2013, and is posted because apparently the film will be released for an Oscar qualifying run in New York and LA this Friday. The version I saw was in Japanese, with subtitles, which is what is being released this week. The film will apparently go wider sometime in 2014 – when it will have been dubbed into English.