Monday, October 28, 2013

Movie Review: The Counselor

The Counselor
Directed by: Ridley Scott.
Written by: Cormac McCarthy.
Starring: Michael Fassbender (The Counselor), Penélope Cruz (Laura), Cameron Diaz (Malkina), Javier Bardem (Reiner), Brad Pitt (Westray), Rosie Pérez (Ruth), Richard Cabral (The Young Man/The Green Hornet), Natalie Dormer (The Blonde), Édgar Ramírez (The Priest), Bruno Ganz (The Diamond Dealer), Rubén Blades (Jefe), Goran Višnjić (Michael), Toby Kebbell (Tony), Emma Rigby (Tony's Girlfriend), John Leguizamo (Randy), Dean Norris (The Buyer), Fernando Cayo (Abogado Hernandez).

I saw the Coen’s Brothers No Country for Old Men twice in fairly packed theaters – once at TIFF in 2007 and then again a few months later with my wife. Both times, after Tommy Lee Jones brilliant final monologue, when the screen turns black and silent, and the credits start rolling, I heard more than one audience exclaim “That’s it!” I know my experience is not singular to me – many have reported the same thing at screenings of the film back in 2007. And you really cannot blame the audience members who exclaimed it either – after all, movies condition us to expect a certain resolution, that No Country for Old Men does not give us. The main character is murdered – off-screen – his killer, the heartless killing machine of a villain, has walked away free, and the lawman who was chasing him has admitted he’s giving up. It’s a dark ending, a troubling ending, but a fitting and brilliant one.

Ridley Scott’s The Counselor is clearly a film by the same author of No Country for Old Men. The two taglines the Coen brother’s masterpiece used in their posters “There Are No Clean Getaways” and “You Can’t Stop What’s Coming” could easily be used for The Counselor as well. Whether Josh Brolin’s Llewyn Moss knows it or not, his fate is sealed the moment he takes the money from the dead drug dealers he stumbles upon. The Counselor (Michael Fassbender) has his fate sealed even before the movie begins. He’s warned – repeatedly – that once he goes down this path, he’s screwed, but he dives headlong in anyway.

Because the film is directed by Ridley Scott, who is known for mainstream fare, and has an all-star cast, and yes, because it’s been marketed like a mainstream thriller, it’s no wonder that most audiences – and critics – expected just that. But that is really not what Scott, and McCarthy writing his first original screenplay, have made in The Counselor. It’s almost an anti-thriller. Complaining that you can see the plot twists coming from early in the film is beside the point – there’s not even a real plot twist in the movie at all. It’s clear that McCarthy isn’t interested in writing a typical thriller – or even a screenplay that follows the normal rules we are conditioned to expect. The plot details in The Counselor are hazy because they don’t really matter all that much (although by the end, you can piece together everything that happens as long as you pay attention). This is a cold, heartless, violent film about inevitability – and indicates as much almost from the start. If at any times during The Counselor you expect a happy ending, you aren’t paying attention.

The film stars Fassbender as the unnamed lead character – a lawyer, who we first see under the covers with his soon-to-be fiancée Laura (Penelope Cruz). Soon we’ll see him meet two men – Reiner (Javier Bardem) and Westray (Brad Pitt), and we’ll understand the basics of what is happening. The Counselor has set up a drug deal with a Mexican cartel, using Reiner and Westray as middle men. They are importing $20 million worth of cocaine using massive, rundown trucks from Mexico to Chicago. We meet other characters – like the heartless Malkina (Cameron Diaz), the current girlfriend of Reiner, who has a cheetah fetish. Then there’s Ruth (Rosie Perez), a client of The Counselor who asks for his help getting her son out of jail on a speeding charge – this seemingly innocent request, that The Counselor does without thinking, is what will eventually screw everything up.

Many, if not most, reviews of The Counselor have complained about the pretentious dialogue – that goes on for minutes on end, and happen in scene after scene. But the dialogue in The Counselor is one of its greatest strengths. When did we start expecting movie dialogue to sound the way real people talk? The dialogue in The Counselor is highly stylized to be sure, but it’s also brilliant. This is one of the most quotable films of the year. The dialogue has a rhythm all its own, and the cast digs into it with gusto. My favorite may well be Brad Pitt, particularly in his first scene in a bar, where he lays for The Counselor precisely what he can expect – but his warning falls on deaf ears. But there are pleasures to be had watching any of the characters dig into the monologues McCarthy gives them – Bardem, saying more in his first scene here than in all of No Country for Old Men and Diaz making the most of getting playing the most amoral character in a film filled with nothing but amoral characters. And then there are the characters who only get one scene but make the most of them – Perez, reminding you why she is a better actress than she ever got credit for, Bruno Ganz going on about diamonds and their imperfections, Edgar Ramirez as a Priest who has no interest in Diaz’s confession, Ruben Blades as a man who waxes philosophical while threatening certain death, Toby Kebbell showing that The Counselor may have made more mistakes than just this one and John Leguizamo explaining to Dean Norris a particularly sick joke by Columbians. Fassbender is very good in the movie as well – but he’s also the film’s most passive character – sitting there and listening to everyone else, but never letting anything really sink in until it’s too late.

The Counselor may not be a perfect film – there are certainly flaws here. No matter how much I love the dialogue, it is true that the characters never really rise above the level of archetypes (although, again, I think it’s intentional). I cannot really complain about those who say the film is misogynistic – there are really only two female characters with any screen time, and Cruz’s Laura is presented as pretty much the embodiment of female perfection – or at least a man’s idea of female perfection – and Diaz is presented as her polar opposite – a heartless, she-devil. And the now infamous scene of Diaz literally having sex with Bardem’s car is unnecessary (as this scene is told by Bardem to Fassbender, it would have worked much better without the visual staging of the scene). But I still have to say, Diaz goes for broke – not just humping the car, but in her every scene in the movie. And to be fair, I don't quite think the film is misogynistic as much as it's mianthropic - it's not like any of the male characters are portrayed any better than the female ones.
 
The Counselor is a movie that most people are going to hate. It’s cold, it’s violent, it’s cynical and it doesn’t deliver the traditional payoffs we expect when we go see a star studded thriller or a Ridley Scott movie. But for me, it’s one of the best films of Scott’s career. Good for him diving headlong into McCarthy’s dialogue, and making a polished film out of the product – not the kind he would normally make (or the kind his brother, the late Tony Scott would make, although some critics have compared this to those film for reasons that escape me - yes, there is a superficial similarlity to some of the dark themes that run through Tony Scott's work, but stylistically it's far removed from his work, although perhaps there is something to be said about Ridley making a movie this dark after his brother's suicide) – but instead the movie that demands to be made out of McCarthy’s screenplay. And good for the actors who dive headlong into the movie, and make the most of the opportunity to deliver the type of dialogue that we almost never see in the movies. Yes, most people will hate The Counselor. Good for them. For a few people however, The Counselor is a special movie. I’m one of those people.

Movie Review: All is Lost

All is Lost
Directed by: J.C. Chandor.
Written by: J.C. Chandor.
Starring: Robert Redford (Our Man).
 
It’s hard, if not near impossible, to make a film about a solitary character by themselves. It’s why the few attempts we’ve had at it over the years have added certain elements to make the films more palatable. So Cast Away (2000) adds a volleyball with a face to give Tom Hanks someone to talk to for the long middle stretch of the movie, Life of Pi (2012) adds in a framing device of the man telling his story to someone else, which allows a lot of voice over narration. The recent Austrian film The Wall has the title character, who is cut off for the rest of humanity, write her story down and narrate over nearly the entire movie. Silence is scary for filmmakers, because how can they convey their characters inner lives, if they never talk?

All of this makes J.C. Chandor’s All is Lost even more impressive than it already is. Here is a film with one actor in its entire running time – who aside from a small voiceover in the first few minutes of the film, that still doesn’t answer all the questions people will have about the character, and a few isolated words yelled either in frustration or to try and attract attention – doesn’t even contain dialogue. The film is all Robert Redford, on a boat, trying desperately to survive – and nothing else. And yet, Redford’s performance is one of the best of the year, even if we never get to know the character’s inner self – or even his name. It doesn’t matter.

The movie opens with a literal bang – as Redford awakes under deck on his yacht, to discover he has just hit a shipping container. He’s in the middle of the Indian Ocean, surrounded by nothing but water, and knows his boat has a sizable leak. We see him disentangle his boat from the container, and realize that all his electronic equipment has been rendered useless by the water. We see him patch the boat, and hatch a plan. He’s going to steer his boat into the shipping lanes fairly close by and hope to be able to catch the attention of a passing boat to be rescued. He has no motor, just his sails – and has to teach himself how to navigate by the stars. He has little hope of survival, but he’s going to try anyway.

Robert Redford is, surprisingly, the perfect actor to play the lead role – identified in the credits as Our Man. He was once one of the biggest movie stars in the world – the George Clooney of his day, as he was a sex symbol who was loved by women, but still relatable to men. And also because, like Clooney, Redford also directed movies – and didn’t just cruise on his movie star charm and good looks (although he could do so when he wanted to). Now 77, Redford is well past his prime as a movie star – his last few films both in front of and behind the camera pretty much came and went without making an impact – but Redford is still the old movie star he always has been. Chandor casts him because of that movie star persona – he is an actor audiences instinctively like and root for – which given that the role doesn’t give him any backstory except that he is a man, alone on a boat, and he has some regrets (which could apply to anyone) is needed here.

All is Lost is a simple film – it is a film about the inevitability of death, and how we all struggle against that inevitability. Age simply brings death closer, and intensifies that struggle. Redford makes this clear throughout the film, as at times, he struggles doing things his younger self would have been able to handle easier – the pumping of water out of the boat, scaling the masts on the yacht, etc. Redford’s performance is almost entirely physical – and it’s remarkable how much he shows the physical and mental strain on his body and mind as the film moves along. Redford is almost the whole show here, and it’s a great one.

The film was written and directed by J.C. Chandor, and that’s surprising given that his only other film as a director was Margin Call (2011) – a very good film about the Wall Street meltdown, which was nothing but talk for its entire running time. I’ve heard some theories connecting All is Lost with Margin Call – saying the film is about the Wall Street meltdown, because it’s about an old, rich white guy on a sinking boat, trying in vain to bail his way out. To me, that’s stretching it more than a little bit. All is Lost is simpler than that – it is about one man, trying to survive. It’s wonderfully made by Chandor, who keeps his focus tightly on Redford throughout – and does great things visually and in particularly aurally – in his filmmaking. But the reason to see the film is Redford – without him, the movie doesn’t work at all. Is it the best performance of Redford’s career? Perhaps, but that’s hard to say, because everything he’s done before All is Lost informs his performance here. An unknown in the lead simply would not have the same impact, even if the performance was the same. This is Redford taking a chance – there are lots of ways this movie, and performance, could have gone horribly wrong. But somehow, it never does.

Movie Review: Escape from Tomorrow

Escape from Tomorrow
Directed by: Randy Moore.
Written by: Randy Moore.
Starring: Roy Abramsohn (Jim), Elena Schuber (Emily), Katelynn Rodriguez (Sara), Jack Dalton (Elliot), Danielle Safady (Sophie), Annet Mahendru (Isabelle), Lee Armstrong (Man on Scooter), Alison Lees-Taylor (Other Woman), Stass Klassen (Scientist).

I’ve never been to Disneyland or Disneyworld, but I understand the urge to look for the dark side of the so-called Happiest Place on Earth. Disney works very hard to keep a squeaky clean image – the commercials for their theme parks promise nothing but non-stop family fun – which is what they want you to associate everything Disney with. They want to be controversy free – and have no problem suing any and everyone who does something they don’t like. The most remarkable thing about Randy Moore’s Escape from Tomorrow then is that it exists at all – and you don’t have to watch some illegal, bootleg copy to get to see the movie itself. Moore and his cast snuck cameras into both Disneyland and Disneyworld over the course of several months, and filmed their movie right in the middle of the park. The movie is specifically about the darkness lurking behind the façade of the happiest place on earth – with sexual undercurrents, insanity, violence and crazed scientists under Epcot center. Moore has tapped into that darkness in Disney that the company works very hard to convince you aren’t there at all. When the film premiered at Sundance, everyone assumed it would never be released – although according to legal experts, Disney didn’t have much of a case, people assumed they would tie the movie in litigation so long that by the time they lost, no one would care anymore. Surprisingly though, Disney did the right thing – and simply ignored the movie. This is a tiny movie, that won’t be viewed by all that many people. Why look like a corporate bully when few will even see the film in the first place?

The film opens with Jim (Roy Abramsohn) getting a phone call telling him he is being let go from his job. This couldn’t come at a worst time, since he’s about to go spend the final day of his family vacation at Disneyland. Once he gets to the park, it doesn’t take him long to start to lose it – fueled by alcohol, he starts having bizarre fantasies – revolving around two, young French girls, who he follows behind like a creepy stalker, with his young son in tow. On the It’s a Small World ride, the faces of the children become distorted and surreal. He has ugly encounters with other park guests. His wife won’t stop bitching at him – his son won’t stop whining about Buzz Lightyear, and he will eventually end up the subject of bizarre experiments at Epcot center.

It must be said that the idea behind Escape from Tomorrow is better than the execution. After establishing Disneyland as a dark place, full of secrets and a corporate conspiracy or two, and establishing Jim as a man coming apart at the seams, the movie doesn’t really go anywhere. It’s content to come up with bizarre imagery, distorting the vision of Disney as the happiest place on earth, and have Abramsohn rage at anything and everything around him. It would have helped a little if any of the other characters were developed in the slightest – Jim’s wife is portrayed pretty much as a harpy – and his son as snot nosed whiner. By comparison, his daughter comes across the best – a sweet faced little girl – until the inevitable scene where she wants something her parents don’t want to buy her, and she devolves into a temper tantrum.

Yet, it also must be said that while the movie is too long – it could have made a brilliant 30 minute short for instance – it is also effective much of the time. I may have never been to Disneyland, but as the father of a two-year old, I do know just how painful it can be to keep a fake smile plastered on your face as you’re stuck watching something insultingly simplistic, or suffering through live shows aimed at children (the Thomas the Tank Engine live show was the longest 30 minutes of my life – I can only imagine how much alcohol the poor girl who had to sing the thing every day must have to drink). Escape from Tomorrow taps into that futile, impotent rage that all parents go through at one point or another. Most of the time, I suffer gladly because my daughter loves the Bubble Guppies so much – but once in a while…

It also taps into our fascination with Disney, and its dark side. Do a quick search on the internet, and you’ll find all sorts of evil conspiracies involving Uncle Walt, Disneyland and everything else associated with Disney. This is a massive corporation, built to make money, which also tries to present itself as totally family friendly and innocent. Of course, they’re bringing it on themselves in some ways.

You have to give Randy Moore credit. I don’t necessarily think Escape from Tomorrow is a very good movie – it’s trying hard to be David Lynch Goes to Disneyland, and cannot pull it off. Isolated moments work far better than the movie as a whole. But he’s made something interesting here – a film that everyone is talking about, even if few people will actually end up watching it. In that way it’s brilliant – how many first time directors, working with no budget and no stars can say they’ve done that? Hopefully Moore, who has made a mess of a film this time out, can turn this into an interesting career. The ideas are there.

Movie Review: Birth of the Living Dead

Birth of the Living Dead
Directed by: Rob Kuhns.
 
DVD special features have made making of documentaries common place. Every movies – from masterpieces to crap – now have their entire making of documented and put out there for all to see. The new documentary, Birth of the Living Dead, plays like one of those special features on a DVD – but an uncommonly good one. It doesn’t rival the best documentaries of the genre – like Hearts of Darkness: A Filmmaker’s Apocalypse (about Apocalypse Now) or Burden of Dreams (about Fitzcaraldo), but it’s still worth seeing for fans of George A. Romero’s Night of the Living Dead, even if perhaps the only reason it’s not just a special feature on a DVD of the film is because a screw-up has made the film be in the public domain pretty much since its release back in 1968.

If you were going to make a list of the best Do-It-Yourself movies, than Night of the Living Dead would have to be on that list. It is a film that George A. Romero directed for almost no money, with a cast of unknowns, and a crew who, like him, had never made a movie before. If you were going to make a list of the most influential horror films of all time, than Night of the Living Dead would have to be on that list as well – the entire zombie genre as we now know it was pretty much invented by Romero with this film. Either of those two factors would be enough to make a documentary about Night of the Living Dead relevant – both of them practically make it necessary.

Directed by Rob Kuhns, Birth of the Living Dead is a standard issue documentary – filled with talking heads, and clips of the movie under discussion. Kuhns does not reinvent the wheel when directing the film, in part because he didn’t really need to. He has good talking heads, and the movie in question is fascinating enough to warrant such discussion.

The film details how Romero and his funders and crew made Night of the Living Dead on the fly back in 1967, and then released the film in 1968. Romero didn’t have much money – he didn’t know if he would ever finish the film – but he wanted to make a movie, and found enough like-minded people who wanted to do so as well. At first he wanted to make something more artistic – he talks about writing a screenplay inspired by Ingmar Bergman’s The Virgin Spring, but when no one cared, he decided to do something more horrific and commercial – and came up with Night of the Living Dead.

As the movie makes clear, Night of the Living Dead was a product of its time. Not only is it a horror film, it’s a nihilistic one at that – one in which reflects the era in which it was made. It’s clear that the film has something to say on many social issues of the time – the ongoing war in Vietnam, racism and destruction of the nuclear family. In short, nowhere and no one is safe in Night of the Living Dead – the dead can get you anywhere, and anyone can turn against you. Yet Romero never overindulges in the political or social messages of the film – he has made a straight ahead horror movie first and foremost, but one that captures much of the cynicism of its time. It’s fascinating to note for instance that the lead character, played by Duane Jones, was black was merely a coincidence – Romero didn’t write the role for a black man, and when they cast one, he didn’t change the screenplay at all, even if it somewhat feels like he did.

Romero himself is the best interview subject – although film critic Elvis Mitchell is good as well. Romero is quick witted and funny – and easygoing, giving full credit to all his collaborators, and joking about the whole process. Romero has, of course, continued to make zombies films throughout his now 45 year directing career – he has said he wanted to make, and he’s now up to 6. He better get cracking on the next four – especially since Survival of the Dead (2009), his latest, is also his weakest.

Birth of the Living Dead is not a great documentary – but it is a good one. If you want to see the roots of the modern zombie film, or are interested in Romero at all, than you should see it. For people who are not zombie fans, there’s nothing here to see – but then, why would you be interested in the film anyway?

My Answer to the Latest Criticwire Survey Question: Off Screen Information

Q: The very public feud between actress Lea Seydoux and her Blue Is the Warmest Color director Abdellatif Kechiche has become as well-known as the film itself. Should critics ignore off-screen information in reviewing a film, or do they have an obligation to deal with it?

I, obviously, have not seen Blue is the Warmest Color yet – it doesn’t open in Toronto until November 8th – which is when I plan to see it. When I do review the movie however, I won’t deal with the many off-screen antics that have happened in the last few months – unless they are relevant to what we are seeing onscreen.

I’m not going to recap the whole feud – if you’re at all interested in it, you’ve probably already read all about it, and if not it’s not hard to find. For the most part, I do have to say that director Abdellatif Kechiche sounds like an asshole, and also somewhat ridiculous with his criticisms of Seydoux – even going as far last week to say she has to answer for what she said in court. Is he going to sue her? For what, calling him an asshole?

It doesn’t really matter to me what Kechiche did to get the scenes he did. Except in extreme cases (like saying film rape or murder or other such crimes), directors have often engaged in questionable tactics to get what they want. Sometimes, it’s relevant, and sometimes it’s not. It all depends on the movie itself.

It is not irrelevant for instance to talk about Woody Allen and Mia Farrow’s divorce when discussing Allen’s Husbands and Wives however – the last film they made together, which debuted during the nasty tabloid fodder that surrounded their separation, because the film addresses some of the issues they were going through. It’s also not irrelevant to talk about Roman Polanski’s predilection for young women when discussing Tess (1980) – since it was a film he made after running away from a conviction of raping a child, while in a relationship with his then underage star of the film – or discussing how editing his film The Ghost Writer while under house arrest, effects the results. Those things inform what we see on screen. On a completely different level, Robert Redford’s performance in All is Lost is great in large part because we, as the audience, have a long history with him as an actor – and unknown 77 year old actor in the same role would not have the same impact, even if he delivered the “same” performance as Redford.

But in the end, what really matters is what’s onscreen and what’s not. Kechiche seems like an asshole in his recent rantings and ravings to be sure, but if he made a masterpiece, I’ll have no problem saying so. And if I don’t think he made a masterpiece, it won’t because of his behavior. It’s naïve to think we can block out everything we hear about a movie and the circumstances in which it’s made when we watch the film. But you do have to decide what’s relevant to what’s onscreen and what’s not.

So basically, I have a cop out of an answer – what happens off screen is not relevant to what onscreen – unless it is. Do with that what you will.

Movie Review: The Wall

The Wall
Directed by: Julian Pölsler   
Written by: Julian Pölsler based on the novel by Marlen Haushofer.
Starring: Martina Gedeck (Frau).

Movies excel at a lot of things that novels do not – and vice versa. Not having read the book that is the basis of the Austrian film The Wall, I cannot say if it was one of those “unadaptable” books or not – but I do know that writer/director Julian Polsler probably could not have picked a worse way into turning the book into a movie. While the film is never less than beautiful to look at, and Martina Gedeck delivers a fine performance in the lead (and really only) role, The Wall commits the capital cinematic sin of telling, not showing and if nothing else shows future directors just how not to make a movie like this.

The film stars Gedeck as the unnamed protagonist of the story, who goes out to an isolated cabin in the woods with two friends. The friends head into town for a little while the first night, leaving Gedeck in the cabin alone with a dog named Lynx. When she wakes up the next morning, her friends still are not back – so she decides to head into town, on foot, herself. And that’s when she discovers it – the invisible wall that has trapped her, alone, in the middle of nowhere. Like the dome in Stephen King’s Under the Dome you cannot see this wall, cannot get over it, or under it and Gedeck has no idea where it came from. Walking back to the cabin, she sees two other people outside their cottage – and tries to talk to them. But, they are on the other side of the wall, and no matter how loud she screams, they cannot hear or see her. Then she realizes something – they aren’t moving. It’s like time has frozen outside the Wall.

The movie takes place over the days, weeks, months and finally years that Gedeck spends inside the wall – with no other people around, just her animals to keep her company. The wall has enclosed a huge space for her in the middle of nowhere – a forest, fields and lots of wildlife are inside with her and gradually she learns to take care of herself – how to harvest the crops growing inside, and hunt the animals. She bonds with Lynx the dog, and eventually with two cats she finds, along with a pregnant cow – and eventually the calf. The animals keep her going.

The problem with the movie is the near constant voiceover narration by Gedeck. We see her at the beginning sit down and begin to write down what she has experienced over her still ongoing time behind the Wall – which I would guess is the premise of the book as well. Over practically every moment of every scene, we her Gedeck’s voice narrating the action we see on the screen. She hardly says a word otherwise. The narration, which explains every thought and feeling Gedeck is experiencing onscreen, robs the movie of any real power. Reading a first person narrative can be very effective – having a constant voiceover is distracting in the extreme, especially in a movie like this.

After all, The Wall is ultimately about loneliness and solitude. Gedeck spends her days consumed by her tasks to try and stave off depression and loneliness, which she can only do for so long. It’s hard to make a film with only one character for nearly its entire running time – it’s why so few movies actually attempt to do it. When they work – like Robert Zemeckis’ Castaway (or apparently the upcoming All is Lost), they can be marvelous. But the fact that we have a near constant drone of a narrator robs the movie of its power – and its ability to make us truly relate to the loneliness and solitude Gedeck is experiencing. Worse, the narration is often not very interesting, and borders on the ponderous. It wouldn’t surprise me to discover that Polsler simply transcribed much of the novel – because a lot of what we hear is the type of narration that may well work on the page, but sounds slightly silly when spoken aloud.

All of this is a shame, because The Wall looks beautiful – shot in the pristine wilderness, that the movie makes look beautiful or scary, depending on the moment. And Gedeck’s physical performance conveys so much without the narration, that I wonder if the movie would have played much better without any narration at all – that certainly would have been a more daring choice.

As it stands, The Wall is a missed opportunity. The constant narration doesn’t work at all, and detracts from the parts of the movie that do work. It’s impossible to watch The Wall and not wonder what kind of movie it would have been – and could have been – had no narration been added at all. At the very least, it would have been a much more daring film.

Thursday, October 24, 2013

Movie Review: Wadjda

Wadjda
Directed by: Haifaa Al-Mansour.
Written by: Haifaa Al-Mansour.
Starring: Reem Abdullah (Mother), Waad Mohammed (Wadjda), Abdullrahman Al Gohani (Abdullah), Ahd Kamel (Ms. Hussa), Sultan Al Assaf (Father).

The fact that a film like Wadjda exists at all should be cause for celebration. Movie theaters are banned in Saudi Arabia, and women are still banned from doing pretty much anything unless they are accompanied by a man. And yet, somehow Haifaa Al-Mansour, a woman, was able to write and direct a feature film in Saudi Arabia, about a smart little girl, who wants to do things that a “proper” young girl in Saudi Arabia would not want to do. While the movie has caused controversy in Saudi Arabia, the country also selected it as their first submission ever for the Foreign Language Film Oscar. It may be a very small step – representing very little progress – but it’s something.

The film stars young Waad Mohammed as Wadjda – a girl of around 11 who more than anything in the world wants a shiny new bike, so she can ride around with her best friend Abdullah (Abdullrahman Al Gohani). Proper young women do not ride bikes, but Wadjda doesn’t care. She already angers Ms. Hussa (Ahd Kamel), the headmistress at her school, because she doesn’t wear the proper head gear, or shoes, and doesn’t immediately hide herself away while playing when two men start working on a rooftop nearby, meaning – shock – that they could see the little girls playing. There is going to be a Qur’an contest at the school – and top prize in 1,000 Riel – enough to buy the bike of her dreams – so she fakes turning over a new leaf and says that she would like to join Religion Club to prepare for the contest.

Wadjda also has a complicated home life. Her mother works as a nurse, but only when she can get to the hospital – which she cannot do if their demeaning driver refuses to show up for work – which he does on some days. Her father (Sultan Al Assaf) leaves for days or weeks on end, and her mother (Reem Abdullah) has heard that her mother-in-law is trying to fix him up with a new wife – one that will give him a son, instead of just a daughter. When Wadjda sees her father’s family tree – and realizes that she isn’t on it, she adds a leaf herself – only to later find it crumpled on the floor. While outwardly, her father is kind to both her mother and Wadjda, it’s also quite clear that he values Wadjda less because she’s a girl, and not a boy.

The film balances between its neo-realist influences, and a more trying to put a brighter face on this story, which could have been a whole lot darker. Given the way Al-Mansour shoots, and the story that revolves around a bike, it’s hard not to think about Vittorio De Sica’s Bicycle Thieves – which is clearly an influence. While Wadjda is definitely critical of Saudi society’s treatment of women, it doesn’t get bogged down in darkness, or play like a sermon. Instead, it makes its points against the treatment of women subtly, and then moves on. The fact that Al-Mansour essentially crafts a feel-good movie out of this story, which one suspects may be darker if it happened in real life, allows her to get away with a little bit more criticism than she may otherwise have been able to do. That may seem like Al-Mansour is soft-pedaling her message a little bit – which isn’t exactly untrue – but keep in mind she had to direct all of the outside scenes in the movie from inside a van – so she wouldn’t be seen by others bossing around men. Wadjda may be a small step in the right direction – but it’s still a step.

I found it impossible not to be won over by Wadjda. The movie is charming and funny, but also has a message – one that I think is important. In the West, we may be shocked with how women are treated in some parts of the world – I love my two-year daughter more than anything in the world – but that’s not true everywhere. Wadjda is not a great movie – it is a little too simplistic than that – but it’s an important one.